Day 6: Favorite Young Adult Novel

Before I begin this post, an admission… I don’t think that I have ever read a “Young Adult” novel, even as a young adult. I have a vague memory of being forced to read a book titled My Darling, My Hamburger my freshman year of high school, and I also remember finding the book as ridiculously bad as the title. As a result, although it’s the only young-adult book I’ve read, I would hardly call it a favorite, and my memory of it is too dim to even begin to write about it.

I will also admit that I considered skipping day six of the challenge entirely, or maybe just stating that I didn’t and hadn’t read any young adult fiction and leaving it at that. But that changed when I spoke to some of my students. I casually mentioned this book challenge to one of my groups, and quickly the class was consumed by reading suggestions from the students. I was so thrilled by their enthusiasm that I decided that we could take a break from history for a while and talk about books. After a good half-hour of plot summaries and excited interruptions by other students with their own suggestions, I was given a short-list of books, (The Book Thief, Hunger Games, Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children, and The Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian) and I promised to buy and read one of them for today’s challenge.

During my lunch time, I headed over to the nearest bookstore and weighed my options. The Book Thief looked excellent, but I didn’t think that one night would be enough time to give it a good, thorough read, and the other books just didn’t appeal to me, except for Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children I’ve always had a bit of an attraction to darker stories, and as I flipped through the pages of the book I was immediately captured by the Victorian era photographs of very odd, and a bit creepy, children. And what a perfectly Gothic title. The decision was made and I walked out with the book.

The story, written by Ransom Riggs, brings those photos to life as the characters that populate this eerie little book. The protagonist is Jacob, a sixteen year old boy who begins to discover that there is much more to both him and the world around him than he could have ever imagined, and that the seemingly apocryphal stories his grandfather used to tell him were grounded in strange, and often disturbing truths. The story itself unfolds in a home for “peculiar children” on a windswept island off of the coast of Wales. The house, although destroyed in a Nazi bombing in 1940, still exists in some kind of a temporal loop, where these children remain safe and hidden. After the sudden and violent death of his grandfather, Jacob embarks on a quest for answers, armed only with the strange photographs his grandfather used to show him, and a mysterious letter. The story that followed was enjoyable, if not a little predictable, and although I did get pretty engrossed in the narrative, I thoroughly disliked the ending which made a sequel all but necessary (and after checking the author’s website, part two has already been confirmed).

What I loved the most about this book were the photographs, and at times the descriptions of the characters that seemed to make those photos come to life. I’ve always tended to get lost in old photographs, creating stories in my mind about who the people were, and what kind of lives they lived. I did it often as a child, constructing entire worlds from my great-grandmother’s treasure trove of old turn-of-the-century photographs, and I still occasionally find myself doing it, specially when looking at those same old amber-hued images. In this book, Riggs does the very same thing except he takes it much further, he builds an entire narrative based on a group of old photos, giving those strangers both a voice and a story. That the photos he based the book on were filled with strange and eerie images of seemingly supernatural children just added the enjoyment that I derived from the book.

As an interesting side note, Riggs acquired the photographs used in his book from the archives of several major collectors. After looking at nearly 100,000 photos, he finally settled on several hundred, out of which he selected 44 to use in this book.

11 thoughts on “Day 6: Favorite Young Adult Novel

  1. This was a hard one for me too. I went straight from Oz to Lolita! I remember enjoying Madeline L’Engle’s Time Quintet series and Ursula LeGuin’s Earthsea books, but to be honest, I can barely recall the plots. Not a good sign. So like you, I am “favoriting” a recent read. I choose Clive Barker’s Abarat books. I stumbled on them one day by accident in the fantasy/science fiction section of the library (an area I don’t usually spend that much time in), and only later found out he targeted them for the “young adult” market. Anyhow, I loved them – especially the idea of this other world made up of islands which are hours of times (i.e. there’s an island for one o’clock, two o’clock etc. And the dreaded Island of Midnight). The heroine’s name is Candy Quackenbush (I love how normal that is). The 3rd book came out last year after a 7 year gap. I’ve yet to read it but it’s on the Kindle. OK, sorry for another long-winded response from me. I just can’t discuss books in a couple of sentences!

  2. Interesting question, and entirely relevant to what I’ve been doing of late. For the past few weeks I’ve been attempting to read my way through the list of all of the Michael Printz Award-winners (YA novel award) plus all the runner-ups. I don’t have a single favorite book or series so far, though I’d say Rick Yancey’s Monstrumologist series, Paolo Bacigalupi’s “Ship Breaker,” and Zusak’s “The Book Thief” are at the top of the heap. I have the Riggs book on my list of things to read next—sounds good!

  3. Pingback: Old Photographs |

  4. Wow, your students have great taste in books. I’ve spent so much time with children’s book authors that I forget that there’s a world of people who don’t know and love children’s literature. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian changes lives, repeatedly. The Book Thief made me sob for hours (I never cry over books.) Having poked about on your site a bit, I think you might really like Octavian Nothing: Traitor to a Nation by M.T. Anderson. And it might surprise you about what a YA novel can be.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s